S3 file attachment is broken

OsamaTbaileh · October 25, 2025, 11:21pm

Im just trying to host frappe lms on my ec2, and I need to link the files with an s3 bucket.

found this app but its kind corrupted Frappe S3 Attachment | Frappe Cloud Marketplace

the “delete file from cloud” option is not working, this option delete file from s3 whenever they are deleted by the user from the ui.

is there any better replacement? or any solution for this?

abhirock74 · October 31, 2025, 2:19am

Hey @OsamaTbaileh
you can try this app for managing cloud asset like AWS S3 and azure blob storage
Cloud asset DocType handel this features.

github.com/Suvaidyam/frappe_theme

Add New Cloud Assets Integration: AWS S3 and Azure Blob Storage

development ← feat-sva-integrations

opened 11:24AM - 03 Oct 25 UTC

abhirock74

+1187 -46

## Description This PR introduces a **brand-new Cloud Assets integration** th…at enables the application to store and manage files in **AWS S3** and **Azure Blob Storage**. It provides full support for file operations, key generation, URL access, and includes comprehensive integration tests. ### Features 1. **S3Operations Class (AWS S3)** - Upload files to S3 with **private or public access**. - Generate unique S3 keys based on **date, doctype, and random strings**. - Sanitize file names by stripping **special characters**. - Read files from S3 and generate **signed URLs**. - Delete files from S3 safely. - Supports credentials from: - Environment variables (`access_key`, `secret_key`) - Cloud Assets doctype fields 2. **AzureBlobOperations Class (Azure Blob Storage)** - Upload files to Azure Blob with **private or public access**. - Generate unique keys using **date, doctype, and random strings**. - Sanitize file names by removing **special characters**. - Read files and generate **signed URLs**. - Delete files safely from Azure Blob Storage. - Supports connection via **Azure credentials** stored in Cloud Assets doctype. 3. **Integration & Unit Tests** - **Positive tests**: - File name sanitization (`strip_special_chars`) - Key generation (`key_generator`) - Upload, read, and delete operations - Signed URL and public URL generation - **Negative tests**: - Uploading non-existent files - Reading or deleting invalid keys - Invalid credentials handling - Tests log a **console message** when skipped due to integration being disabled or incorrect provider. 4. **Error Handling** - Proper handling of `ClientError`, `FileNotFoundError`, and Azure-specific exceptions. - Logs failures from **custom key generator hooks**. --- <img width="1913" height="1034" alt="image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/67a66103-85cf-45c8-bb07-f41267fe1a45" /> <img width="1913" height="1034" alt="image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/a8a488ce-859f-4222-9b64-1fe63c29ae98" /> ## Testing Instructions 1. Configure **Cloud Assets** doctype for either **AWS S3** or **Azure Blob Storage**. 2. Run integration tests: ```bash bench run-tests --app frappe_theme tests/test_s3_operations.py bench run-tests --app frappe_theme tests/test_azure_blob_operations.py