Hey everyone 
I’m trying to install the Healthcare app alongside ERPNext v15 (using the official Docker setup), but it’s not working correctly.
The setup completes without visible errors, yet when I open the site or run bench build, I keep getting this error:
ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'healthcare'
Even though the app is cloned correctly under /home/frappe/frappe-bench/apps/healthcare, it doesn’t load and the site breaks.
What I’ve already tried:
-
Rebuilt custom image from frappe/erpnext:v15.84.0 with Node.js 18 + Yarn preinstalled
-
Verified that ERPNext works fine before adding Healthcare
-
Recreated the site and reinstalled both apps using
bench new-site frontend --mariadb-user-host-login-scope='%' --admin-password=admin
bench --site frontend install-app erpnext
bench --site frontend install-app healthcare
-
Confirmed containers and network are healthy
-
Still getting ModuleNotFoundError during or after setup
Expected:
Healthcare should install and work like any other app on ERPNext v15 Docker setup.
Actual:
ModuleNotFoundError + broken site, even though the app files exist.
Any suggestions or known fixes from anyone who successfully ran Healthcare with ERPNext v15 Docker would be hugely appreciated 
(Tags: erpnext, healthcare, installation_problem, docker)
Are you manually running the command after the core frappe & erpnext has been loaded or you are adding the application using a docker container?
Share your docker compose yaml file?
so first problem is that ERPNext health is now outsourced at GitHub - earthians/marley: Open Source, Enterprise and Modern Health Information System
second problem you cant use bench build/get-app/install-app in docker you need to create docker multi-site and multi-app please use easy-install.py: -
-
wget https://raw.githubusercontent.com/frappe/bench/develop/easy-install.py
-
git clone GitHub - frappe/frappe_docker: Docker images for production and development setups of the Frappe framework and ERPNext
-
In “frappe_docker/development/apps-example.json” edit your apps with their branch: -
[
{ “url”: “https://github.com/frappe/erpnext”, “branch”: “version-15” },
{ “url”: “https://github.com/frappe/hrms”, “branch”: “version-15” },
{ “url”: “https://github.com/frappe/education”, “branch”: “version-15” },
{ “url”: “https://github.com/frappe/crm”, “branch”: “main” },
{ “url”: “https://github.com/frappe/wiki”, “branch”: “master”},
{ “url”: “https://github.com/Aakvatech-Limited/CSF_TZ”, “branch”: “master”}
]
-
python3 easy-install.py build
-
python3 easy-install.py deploy --image=custom-apps --version=latest --sitename=bench3site1.duckdns.org --sitename=bench3site2.duckdns.org --sitename=bench3site3.duckdns.org --app=erpnext --app=hrms --app=education --app=crm --app=wiki --app=csf_tz
For step 4 and 5 if you want more options rather than default values please check out GitHub - frappe/bench: CLI to manage Multi-tenant deployments for Frappe apps
Don’t forget to add the sites to your host file
2 Likes
Hi @asieftejani,
Thanks a lot for the detailed response — that really clarified the Docker part
Just wanted to check one thing: since the original ERPNext Healthcare module is now discontinued and outsourced to Marley by Earthians,
what’s the recommended option now for running healthcare-related use-cases within the Frappe/ERPNext ecosystem?
For example, if someone needs hospital management, patient records, appointments, or lab modules —
should we:
-
Install Marley separately (as a standalone system), or
-
Is there any maintained healthcare app that still works with ERPNext v15 (Docker or non-Docker)?
Would appreciate your guidance on how healthcare setups are being handled in the new ERPNext ecosystem 
Hi @sureshkhichi I’m from the Marley team, not much has changed regrding deployment since the separation of domains from ERPNext core - you can continue using the healthcare module. To answer you -
1 - Marley has a dependency on ERPNext and is not a stand alone Frappe app
2 - There’s no other Healthcare app from Frappe (official). The ownership of maintenance is currently shifted to earthians but I guess its safe to say Marley is the goto app for use in a healthcare setup.
Hope this clarifies.