The float account type is a valuable feature that ERPNext should incorporate. In accounting software, a float account allows for flexible classification based on its balance nature. Specifically, if the account has a credit balance at the end of a period, it can be classified as a liability/income, whereas if it holds a debit balance, it is categorized as an asset/expense. Adding this functionality to the account configuration settings would enhance ERPNext’s adaptability for financial reporting and management.
Are you recommending adding option in account configuration for float type accounts
- Yes
- No
- Not sure
0
voters
Please vote and discuss
Up to be shared
Hi there,
I’ve never encountered an accounting standard that allows this, so I can’t really imagine ERPNext folding it into core. That said, if you need it, couldn’t you just change the account type before issuing a period closing voucher? If that’s all it takes, it’d be easy to automate.
- Accounting Standards and Industry Practices
While traditional accounting standards might not explicitly define a “float account,” the concept is common in certain financial systems, particularly in sectors where accounts need to be reclassified based on their balance nature (e.g., banking, treasury management, or project-based accounting).
Many accounting software systems offer similar functionality, often under different names, to provide flexibility for businesses with unique financial reporting needs. ERPNext’s adaptability could be a competitive advantage by including this feature.
- Automating Period-End Adjustments
Manually changing the account type before issuing a period closing voucher might work for smaller setups but becomes cumbersome for larger organizations or those with multiple accounts requiring reclassification.
Automating the process, as suggested, still requires initial customization, testing, and maintenance. Incorporating this feature into ERPNext natively would save effort and reduce the potential for errors.
- Flexibility and Scalability
A float account type would empower ERPNext users to handle more dynamic business scenarios without frequent manual intervention or workarounds.
This feature would particularly benefit multinational or multi-industry organizations that have to comply with varied reporting requirements, where account nature changes based on regulatory or operational needs.
- Practical Use Case
For instance, an “advances from customers” account might have a credit balance (liability) when customers prepay but could shift to a debit balance (asset) if overpayments occur or adjustments are made. A float account type would simplify handling such scenarios.
- User-Centric Enhancement
ERPNext is known for its user-focused design. Adding this feature would align with that philosophy by addressing diverse accounting needs, potentially increasing adoption in industries that demand such functionality.
- Precedents in ERP Systems
Other ERP systems like SAP, Oracle, or Sage often support dynamic reclassification of accounts, demonstrating the practicality and demand for this feature.
This is a particularly important topic for the reasons I mentioned up.
This is open source software. If this feature is important to you, you are very welcome to make it happen.
Thank you for your response, @peterg I understand that ERPNext is Open Source, but it is also designed for end-users like auditors, accountants, and business managers who rely on its features to meet practical needs. I am an auditor in the UAE, and while I don’t have the technical skills to implement this myself, I can see the significant value it could bring to financial reporting and management processes.
Instead of dismissing the idea, I encourage you to consider sharing this suggestion with the higher tier of your organization. This feature could enhance ERPNext’s functionality and attract more users from industries with dynamic financial reporting requirements. A positive approach to such ideas could contribute to making ERPNext an even more powerful and versatile solution for both developers and end-users.
I don’t work for the organization you seem to think I work for. I’m just another end-user, like you. It is not in my power to accept or dismiss any idea. Good luck!
Float accounts are widely used, especially in the Middle East region, particularly in project-based businesses like contracting and construction.
Currently, in ERPNext:
- Advances can be easily managed using the inbuilt functionality.
- Starting from Version 15, ERPNext supports booking Customer Advances under Liabilities and Supplier Advances under Assets. You can refer to the official documentation here for more details: ERPNext Advance in Separate Party Account.
Regarding other scenarios, a lot can already be managed through Journal Entries:
- PDC (Post-Dated Cheque) Management:
- One way to manage PDC cheques is by using a Payment Entry. You can set the Cheque Date as the posting date and perform the Bank Reconciliation later. On the Receivable or Payable statement, if you choose to “show future payments,” it will display correctly in the report.
- Another approach is to create a dedicated Ledger for PDCs. When you make a payment entry, record it against this PDC ledger, and later, you can do a Journal Entry to reflect the movement in the Bank Ledger once the cheque is cleared.
If you could elaborate on the requirement with a detailed use case, including the accounting impact and ledger details, it would help clarify the exact need. You can also consider opening a feature request on GitHub: ERPNext GitHub Issues.
This way, the development team will be able to evaluate and prioritize this feature based on the broader community’s needs.
1 Like